HUZAIFA SHOUKAT@huzaifabuildz
FAIRFree guide · 1-page PDF

THE FAIR AI CODER SCORECARD

A small experiment you can repeat on your own project.

No email required. Keep it for your next build.

Set up a fair comparison

  1. Give Claude, ChatGPT and Gemini the same project, bug and exact prompt. Start every attempt from the same clean copy.
  2. Back up your tests somewhere the AI cannot edit them. Restore that copy after each attempt and run the tests yourself.
  3. Run each AI at least twice. Keep the model, tool settings and starting files consistent across the comparison.

The task to copy

Fix this bug: [what goes wrong, and the exact error message].
The project is in [folder].
Don't change, delete or skip any test.
When you're done, list every file you changed.

Record each run

Use the downloadable scorecard to record two runs per AI.
AI / runFixed?Tests pass?Untouched?MinutesCost
Claude / 1Record resultRecord resultRecord resultRecord resultRecord result
Claude / 2Record resultRecord resultRecord resultRecord resultRecord result
ChatGPT / 1Record resultRecord resultRecord resultRecord resultRecord result
ChatGPT / 2Record resultRecord resultRecord resultRecord resultRecord result
Gemini / 1Record resultRecord resultRecord resultRecord resultRecord result
Gemini / 2Record resultRecord resultRecord resultRecord resultRecord result

Pick the winner

  1. A run qualifies only when the bug is fixed, the original tests pass, and no test was edited, deleted or skipped.
  2. Compare time and cost among the AIs that qualify in every run. Record actual run charges when available; do not invent a per-run cost for a flat subscription.

KEEP THE GUIDE HANDY

Save the one-page PDF for later.

Download free PDF

TRY NEXT